Pornography in Parliament - or in public - is not really the issue

Andy Churcher • April 29, 2022

A societal seismic shift which we've not seen coming, maybe by choice... 

No-one should be watching pornography in professional working spaces, or in public for that matter, and if proven the MP concerned should be removed from office. But outcry about politicians doesn't get to the root of the problem.

UK police data shows there were 73,260 sexual offences where the victim was a child in the year to March 2019[a] and research demonstrates that 67% of girls and young women have experienced sexual harassment from other students at school[b]. The last 30 years has seen consistent and continuing increases in the free availability of pornography, how explicit and extreme it is, and how it is accessed by children.  Children’s views of sex, relationships and consent is being shaped by pornography and whether through a lack of desire to address this growth, or because no-one really saw it coming, it is now part of many people’s lives.

The normalisation of watching pornography (Ofcom reported 49% of the UK adult population visited online adult content in Sept 2020[c]) fuels the sexual objectification of women and girls - as well as men and boys - and while research is inconclusive as to whether exposure to pornography increases the likelihood of perpetrating sexual violence or harassment, much research identifies the role of pornography in perpetrators lives and how it undermines the notion of consent[d,e+f].

The government’s Online Safety Bill is currently going through parliament and, if it becomes law, will expect “providers who publish or place pornographic content on their services will be required to prevent children from accessing that content”[g]. It’s not clear how this will be implemented and whether such regulation will produce sufficient safeguards, I'm not convinced. 

This is not a technology issue in itself, but an omission by us to tackle the growth in availability of pornography and our attitudes towards it. I do not propose pornography is outlawed and I empathise with people who use it – I did as a young man – but we need to realise that our lack of concern about its growth and impact has had and will have a significant impact on our children and society as a whole.


Sources:

[a] https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/crimeandjustice/articles/childsexualabuseinenglandandwales/yearendingmarch2019

[b] https://www.girlguiding.org.uk/globalassets/docs-and-resources/research-and-campaigns/girlguiding-research-briefing_girls-experiences-of-sexual-harassment_june2021.pdf

[c] https://www.ofcom.org.uk/media-use-and-attitudes/online-habits/interactive/

[d] https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-relationship-between-pornography-use-and-harmful-sexual-behaviours/the-relationship-between-pornography-use-and-harmful-sexual-behaviours

[e] https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/088626087002002005

[f] https://doi.org/10.1002/ab.20367

[g] https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/online-safety-bill-supporting-documents/online-safety-bill-factsheet

4 pics in a row: a child putting on ballet shoes, a football, a school child, a woman in wheelchair
By Andy Churcher April 14, 2025
In any setting, sports clubs, performing arts schools, education or care, trusted adults empower victims of abuse to come forward
By Andy Churcher March 21, 2025
The recently published DfE research report The link between attendance and attainment in an assessment year [1] outlines the significant benefits to schools and their pupils of improving attendance levels. I know that most schools are very proactive when it comes to supporting pupils to increase their attendance, and rightly so. Ofsted are interested in understanding this work during inspections with a recent report stating, “The school has addressed the significant challenges with pupils’ attendance and punctuality through effective actions to support and engage families.” But, of course, attendance isn’t the only factor impacting attainment in assessment. In fact, much research demonstrates that academic success measured by attainment is influenced by the whole life experience of the child. Ofsted’s 2022 paper Securing good attendance and tackling persistent absence [2] identified interdependencies between attendance and safeguarding. Effective and empathetic communication with parents is also an important tool in reducing absence. The same paper noted, “It is clear that leaders who have succeeded in raising attendance levels listen to parents properly and ask the right questions in order to find out why their children are not attending well enough.” There is also extensive research which helps us to understand the link between challenging behaviour and abuse, neglect and exploitation. The Truth Project, part of the Independent Inquiry Into Child Sexual Abuse [3], gathered the insight of more than 6,000 victims and survivors of child sexual abuse. In its report, IICSA noted that victims and survivors knew their behaviour deteriorated as a result of being sexually abused sometimes, but not exclusively, as a deliberate attempt to communicate that they needed help, although sadly these signals were rarely recognised by others. And if behaviour can influence attainment then, of course, so can being the victim of abuse. The Child Safeguarding Practice Review Panel’s 2024 National review into child sexual abuse within the family environment [4] stated that “abuse was reported to have impacted children’s education in nearly a third of reviews”. And, if all that’s the case we can begin to see a complex mosaic of interdependencies for children which have the power to influence their risk of being a victim of abuse, their behaviour in school, their attainment throughout their education and their whole life experience. Safeguarding and wellbeing should never be seen as separate to any other part of a child’s experience. I wonder if school leaders take a truly strategic view of this mosaic which results in a co-ordinated approach which is greater than the sum of its parts. Or if work to support pupils is often too fragmented at an organisational level to be sufficiently effective in tackling these interdependencies. Last year the Department of Education published a rapid literature review [5] to shape the work of the longitudinal Education and Outcomes Panel Study (EOPS). It identified this mosaic of issues that impact educational outcomes categorising them into four themes: Theme 1: Children’s cognitive and non-cognitive capabilities and wellbeing Theme 2: Children with SEND and experience of social services Theme 3: Home environment Theme 4: Experiences of school
A photo of Victoria Climbie smiling at the camera which was used by Lord Laming in his inquiry
By Andy Churcher January 16, 2025
The Children's Wellbeing Bill puts right a quarter of a century of delay
Show More